A Look at the Road Ahead for Dental Sleep Medicine

As a general dentist, you can help close the gap in patients’ access to care.

May 5, 2021
 image
Randy Clare
Glidewell
A Look at the Road Ahead for Dental Sleep Medicine by Randy Clare, Glidewell Hero Image

Recently I was asked by Jason Tierney and Elias Kalantzis from Transform Dental Sleep to participate in a dental sleep medicine webinar by and for leaders in the oral appliance field. It was a privilege to join this event and share from my experiences at Glidewell, which, by case volume, is the single largest dental lab in the world today.

The thoughtful questions that formed the discussion highlighted the forces that have shaped dental sleep medicine in the general dental practice. This dental blog post will cover the top questions that moderators asked during the webinar. I’ve elaborated on these topics to update Smile Bulletin readers on key areas that impact oral appliance therapy (OAT).

There are 30 million apneic people. Why are there so few dentists providing OAT?

It’s a startling number: 30 million people who have trouble sleeping and breathing at the same time. Sadly, the bulk of these patients are undiagnosed and don’t understand their condition well enough to pursue treatment. The potential health implications are clear: diabetes, stroke, heart disease and early death.

In my day-to-day job, I work with general dentists who predominantly serve a community of healthy people who are proactive in taking care of themselves. According to the CDC, nearly 65% of Americans aged 18 and over saw a dentist in 2019. I believe our mission in the dental industry — as professionals who are mindful of snoring and sleep apnea — is to improve access to care for patients who can benefit from dental sleep medicine. And I hope that as the sleep IQ of the general population of the country improves, we will begin to address the 30 million people who are unaware of or don’t believe they have a problem.

Over our half-century in business, we at Glidewell have been working to improve access to care by using innovation to reduce the cost of dentistry. The Silent Nite® Sleep Appliance, our device for the treatment of snoring and sleep apnea, is a great example of this mission. The Silent Nite appliance was introduced to the snoring and sleep apnea therapy field in 1996. Over the past 25 years, nearly 500,000 appliances have been delivered to patients.

General dentists have found the Silent Nite appliance to be easy to deliver because the tools and techniques required are the same as those required to make and deliver a standard nightguard or retainer. An upper and lower impression and a comfortable protrusive bite, via digital or VPS impressions, yield a device that fits the teeth and positions the mandible anteriorly.

As treated patients may feel anxiety about losing or breaking their appliance, we have also started offering a $97 discount on a duplicate backup appliance through the Glidewell Clinical Twinpak™. Clinicians can now deliver two appliances made on the same models for a consistent fit and at a reduced cost.

The Glidewell Clinical Twinpak

The Glidewell Clinical Twinpak affords patients reliable and continuous treatment for snoring and sleep apnea.

Dentists I have spoken with who do not treat sleep apnea are responding to the nonclinical aspects of this treatment, such as medical insurance and the impact on practice workflows. Diagnosis and management of sleep apnea, a medical condition, requires a physician referral. Payment is often tied to medical insurance, and, for patients aged 65 and older, Medicare and Medicaid are the payers. The additional expense of these changes to administrative workflow and the cost of additional training just doesn’t seem to be worth the disruption to the dental office.

At Glidewell, we have distilled the process of treating dental patients for sleep-disordered breathing, a condition that includes snoring and sleep apnea, and have developed a simplified process of provisional care called PMAD (provisional mandibular advancement device) therapy.

Essentially, the dental team screens the patient for sleep-disordered breathing, initiates treatment with an oral appliance, and refers the patient for medical management by a physician. This process is effective and is not disruptive to the dental practice, and it is scalable enough to address the masses when they visit the dental practice for teeth cleaning or other dental procedures.

When will the inflection point be reached?

We will know we have reached the inflection point when the treatment of the many is no longer in the hands of the few. There is nothing about OAT that the general dentist in any town in the U.S. cannot accomplish with the materials they use every day.

It’s estimated that there are 140,000 general dentists in the U.S. The American Dental Association (ADA) states that 52% of American adults report seeing their dentist every six months. There are more than 255 million adults in the U.S. Dentists will be having conversations with some 125 million of them twice this year. We know that 62 million or so have some form of sleep-disordered breathing. Screening and education is critical to success with this patient population.

I believe that if all dentists screened 100% of their patients for sleep-disordered breathing, the way we understand the condition would be transformed. Simply asking patients if they snore or find themselves feeling excessively sleepy in the afternoon as part of a health history would be a great start. Adding the Epworth Sleepiness Scale or STOP-Bang Questionnaire to new patient and patient recall forms would be ideal.

Also, start treatment as soon as a primary complaint like snoring or bed partner disturbance is identified. The treatment of snoring does not require a physician’s prescription or an objective diagnosis. At Glidewell, we developed the process of provisional mandibular appliance device therapy that lets any dentist treat snoring as a standard offering in the dental office, just like a BruxZir® Zirconia crown, Simply Natural Dentures or a Comfort H/S Bite Splint.

This process begins with the simple question: “Do you snore, and would you like to stop?” If the answer is yes, then the patient is fitted with a custom mandibular advancement device (MAD), such as a Silent Nite appliance, OASYS Hinge ApplianceEMA® device or dreamTAP appliance. After the patient is advised that snoring is a symptom of apnea, a physician referral is provided and informed consent documents are added to the patient record. (This is very important. Click here for an example.)

The Silent Nite Sleep Appliance, OASYS Hinge Appliance, EMA device or dreamTAP appliance Chart

As soon as a primary complaint like snoring or bed partner disturbance is identified, dentists may fit the patient provisionally with a mandibular advancement device, such as the Silent Nite Sleep Appliance, OASYS Hinge Appliance, EMA device or dreamTAP appliance.

The patient pays for the appliance out of pocket and the medical management of the case is provided by the patient’s physician. It is important to note that about 50% of the patients in the office have some form of sleep-disordered breathing, but only an estimated 9% of women and 24% of men suffer from obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). For dentists, the treatment is the same: a mandibular advancement device. It is only management of the patient that changes, and a physician or sleep specialist is the obvious referral for any patient who presents with these symptoms.

How do we change the OAT-to-CPAP Rx ratio?

I recently read a document, produced by the clinical advisory team at Philips Respironics, titled “Seeking solutions: how COVID-19 changed sleep around the world.” On Page 6 (if you are reading along with me), I was struck by the statistic that continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) compliance in 2021 compared to 2020 had decreased by nearly 50%. Their survey found that only 18% of CPAP patients are using their CPAP.

They also report that 16% of diagnosed sleep apnea patients who received their CPAP in 2021 have never turned it on. The percentage was only slightly better in 2020 (it was 10%).

Compare this track record with oral appliance therapy. One study found that compliance was excellent compared to other therapies, with 90% of patients still using their appliance after two-and-a-half years.

The big question is this: What is it about the current model that makes CPAP adherence and access to care so poor? If we want to change the ratio, we need to change the general perception of sleep care. This same survey highlighted some critical perceptions in the undiagnosed population:

  • 30% believe that OSA treatment is worse than the disease
  • 27% do not want to know if they have OSA
  • 24% believe that treatment is unnecessary
  • 25% believe that if they were diagnosed, they would not use a CPAP machine

This appears to be a community health education problem, and the dental office is well suited to engage 52% of the population at least two times per year. Let’s start here and refine the dental model in a way that addresses the unmet need of these patients.

If there were only one OAT left on Earth, what should it be?

I don’t believe that appliance design is the determining factor in successfully treating a snoring and sleep apnea patient. There are so many variables that depend on the individual patient. Periodontal condition, a dentist’s experience with the appliance, and the patient’s commitment to treatment are all factors to consider.

I believe that the best appliance is the one that the patient will wear all night, every night. It should also be the appliance that the clinician feels can be fabricated and delivered with a high degree of consistency, so that sleep therapy is not disruptive to the delivery of dental care in the practice.

The Silent Nite Sleep Appliance

The Silent Nite Sleep Appliance is custom fit and designed to be comfortable all night, every night.

The Silent Nite Sleep Appliance is excellent because it is durable and inexpensive, and with a quarter-century of clinical use and nearly 500,000 appliances delivered, it has proven to be effective in the hands of the widest possible range of clinicians.

As of this writing, the Silent Nite appliance is the only custom-fabricated snoring and sleep apnea device that we know of with a money-back guarantee. At Glidewell, our confidence comes from the hundreds of thousands of appliances we have delivered over the years. This appliance is widely regarded as the appliance that made sleep treatment accessible to the widest range of patients and practices.

So, if I had to choose one device, I would pick the Silent Nite Sleep Appliance.

What are the main differences between milled, printed, acrylic and thermoformed sleep appliances?

The selection of materials for dental products at Glidewell comes back to our basic business ethic. As President and CEO Jim Glidewell, CDT, told Dental Tribune when asked to define the company: “Glidewell is not merely a dental laboratory, but a very large research and development operation. Our goal is to help make dentistry accessible for patients of all economic strata, not only for rich people. The more convenient and affordable we can make our products, the closer we can come to helping dentists preserve or restore smiles for everybody.” This is a commitment that has driven all aspects of the Glidewell brand, including dental sleep medicine.

Our analysis has been that thermoformed appliances meet the needs of the widest possible number of patients and clinicians at a price that does not restrict access to care. We are currently shipping Silent Nite Sleep Appliances after only three days in the lab, which is a standard that we are committed to.

Milling is highly accurate, but very expensive. Acrylic is time consuming, labor intensive and difficult to scale, which makes it expensive.

Printed devices hold some promise; however, the resin materials have only just begun to be developed with the rigidity and stability to support and position the weight of the mandible and withstand the forces of bruxism eight to 10 hours per night. There is much to do here, but signs are excellent that printing has the scalability, low cost and price point to make this process attractive.

I am very confident that Glidewell scientists and our R&D team will be able to continue to improve response times and vet materials, processes, and procedures to meet demand for speed of production, balanced with product quality and patient satisfaction.

What do your most and least prolific customers have in common?

Many Glidewell customers share a single commonality: They are general dentists with restorative practices. They serve a community of patients, and the services they offer reflect the needs and desires of that community.

The core of our business model is a focus on speed and quality. Jim Glidewell has developed a focus on mass customization. Making sleep appliances that posture the mandible 3 mm to 6 mm anteriorly to affect an open airway is not that difficult; there are more than 100 appliances that the FDA has cleared for the purpose. The hard work comes when it is time to scale to address the needs of 30 million patients. I believe only Glidewell can do that.

To discover the simple, three-step process to screen and treat patients for snoring and sleep apnea, visit glidewell.com/pmad.

More to Know

Dental CE Webinar

    Related Dental Article

    Send blog-related questions and suggestions to hello@glidewell.com.

    Sleep Dentistry